Real

Sound of Metal (2019): Many Redditors praise this film for its powerful portrayal of a drummer's journey with hearing loss, noting its universal critical acclaim despite its limited mainstream recognition. "I know it is universally well received among critics and won many awards however among the typical person very few people I meet haven't even heard of it."
The Father (2020): This film is lauded for its poignant exploration of dementia, receiving Oscar nominations but still remaining largely unseen by the general public. "It's critically acclaimed and got a couple oscar nominations but is still criminally underseen and just made $2 million in the US and Canada."
May December (2023): Redditors highlight this film as a top movie of the decade that, despite positive reviews, quickly faded from public discussion. "It was well reviewed at the time, but the conversation moved on from it way too quickly."

Sing Street (2016): This movie is frequently mentioned for its feel-good story and incredible soundtrack, making it a beloved yet under-the-radar musical. "Incredible soundtrack too."
Bad Times at the El Royale (2018): Redditors appreciate this film for its strong cast, sharp dialogue, and unexpected twists, wondering why it didn't gain more traction. "The cast is at their best, the dialogue is razor sharp and there's a good few unexpected twists and turns to keep you on the edge of your seat."
Dave Made a Maze (2017): This indie film is recognized for its unique premise and charming execution, offering a fresh take on adventure and creativity. "Dave Made a Maze. (2017)"

Eighth Grade (2018): This coming-of-age film is praised for its painfully realistic depiction of adolescence and social anxiety. "Eighth Grade is peak coming of age cinema, so painfully real, I think it will be seen as a young adult classic alongside films like Booksmart."
The Last Duel (2021): While some found the multi-perspective narrative repetitive, many Redditors now appreciate its depth and an "incredible fight scene."
The Grey (2011): This survival thriller is seen as more than just an action film, delving into themes of death and the will to survive, often compared to poetry. "It’s by no means a masterpiece. And I don’t think it’s necessarily deep themes throughout. However, it’s deeper in how it works on pathos than typical survivalist movies, and it’s more than just people being chased by wolves."